Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Book Review: Python 3 Web Development Beginner's Guide

I recently received a free review copy (eBook version) of


Cover art for Python 3 Web Development Beginner's Guide

from Packt Publishing. I was looking forward to this book, because I haven't really done much Python 3 work yet, and I wanted to see how it could make my life as a web developer better. However, the book wasn't what I expected. Instead of covering the basics of web development and how Python 3 applies, it is more of an introduction to the sorts of concerns that come up when you build a web framework on top of CherryPy. The sample code just happens to be in Python 3.



The Good



The two best parts of the book, to me, were the coverage of writing a jQuery plugin, and growing an ORM that uses metaclasses to provide a compact, readable way to define the models.



The Bad



I have a rather long list of things I didn't like about the book, some of which are a function of the title setting misleading expectations, and some of which I think are just problematic in general.



In general, I didn't care for the examples. Some of this is personal preference: I find that many people (myself included) learn better when they must type in the examples instead of opening up the code and reading through a completed solution. While the book sometimes indicated that something had been left as an exercise to the reader, opening up the sample code showed that the exercise actually had not been left to the reader. This mismatch between what the text of the book says will be in the sample code and what is actually in the sample code occurs in multiple places throughout the book, and gives a sense that the book was sloppily edited.



I also felt the examples in general were too complicated. It's fine to build up a complicated example over the course of a book, but instead we got a task list, a wiki, a Customer Relationship Management (CRM) tool, a spreadsheet, and more. That's an awful lot to distract you from the beginner's principles that you would expect in a book with this title.



I also didn't care for many of the shortcuts taken in the book. In most instances, the book did acknowledge that the approach taken was not appropriate in the real world, but then proceeded with little or no justification for why it was done the way it was. The two examples that really leap out in this category are the password hashing scheme and the
failure to use a template engine.



When the book first introduces authentication, it explains that you should never store passwords in plaintext. This is absolutely correct, but the book then goes on to demonstrate a completely insecure password hashing scheme: UNSALTED SHA1. The author only provides a cursory link to explain what you should actually be doing. In this day and age, demonstrating anything less than a bcrypt-based solution is wrong. Read Enough With The Rainbow Tables and How To Safely Store A Password for a far better explanation than I can provide. There's really no excuse for
this: the added complexity of using py-bcrypt instead of writing your own (insecure) SHA1-based solution is trivial at worst; there's a strong case to be made that it would actually be simpler.



The failure to use a template engine (also a weakness acknowledged by the book) really makes the code harder to follow than it should be. Virtually any serious web development effort is going to take advantage of a template engine, and for good reason. This code gives me flashbacks to my days of writing Java servlets before the advent of JSP, and I saw where one other reviewer invoked the specter of PHP. The fact that this style of coding draws such comparisons should give you an idea of just how unpythonic it is. I would be sympathetic to claims of not wanting to add too many external dependencies if the book did not already rely significantly on the magic of jQuery UI.



My last major complaint is simply one of focus: the book spends substantial amounts of time growing an ORM and teaching Python metaclasses (and doing a good job of it), but spends little
more than the bare minimum required on CherryPy (which is at the core of the code), and essentially none on understanding HTTP. In fact, the few times it comes up is usually in relation to GET vs. POST, where the decision is usually made based on inane implementation details such as whether request arguments are logged by default instead of HTTP fundamentals such as idempotency, safety, or cacheability (although caching is mentioned elsewhere, in the context of how to prevent it). Also, the book does mention security, but it does not give it the sort of omnipresent emphasis that is necessary to write good web applications, given the hostile nature of the domain. XSS, CSRF, and SQL injection attacks all deserve much more attention than they were given.



The Summary



The book has some good content mixed in with the stuff I didn't like. Unfortunately, the good content is rarely specific to web development. For example, the chapter that uses metaclasses to clean up the ORM is one of the better resources on metaclasses that I've seen, but metaclasses are clearly not specific to web development. Furthermore, the impression of sloppy editing makes it hard to put as much faith in the content as it probably deserves. Given these flaws, I really don't think I'd recommend this book to a friend who was looking to get started with web development.



Back to flipping out...

4 comments:

nago said...

interesting blog. It would be great if you can provide more details about it. Thanks you



Web Development

Irene_J said...

Great book for beginning web developers to consider where to start the journey. I’m interested in teaching new web designers and developers foundational skills in my new website. This book will be a big help. Website Design Fort Lauderdale

Sivaraj Palanisamy said...

Nice blog.

Adorn web Development company India

Mike Lowson said...

I happen to be commenting to let you know of the terrific encounter my cousin’s princess gained going through your blog. She learned a wide variety of pieces, including how it is like to have an incredible helping style to get other folks without hassle learn about a variety of complex subject areas. You truly did more than her expected results. Thanks for displaying the valuable, trusted, explanatory and even unique tips about your topic to her.
How I can Create YouTube Channel?